[PD] fundamental hot/cold midi question

Stephen Sinclair radarsat1 at gmail.com
Wed Sep 26 17:57:51 CEST 2007


> Right now I'm pretty confused. What did I miss? In retrospect, it seems
> very odd to me that switching the lines sending velocity ad note in arp
> would have any effect. I would expect those to lines to happen
> "simultaneously" at least from interconnected pd-objects point of view.

Personally I consider this to be a somewhat fundamental problem in Pd:
There is actually no way, looking at an outlet with several lines
coming out of it, to determine what order they will trigger.  It
actually depends on what order you connected them in.
To me this is important information that is simply _missing_ in Pd's
graphical representation.

Note that this is not true in Max/MSP: messages are always triggered
from right to left.

It would be nice to fix it, but unfortunately doing so would probably
affect backwards-compatibility with people's patches.
Anyways, if you have something which absolutely depends on the order
in which a message is sent out multiple connections, insert the [t]
object to re-trigger the same message several times, and make one
connection per outlet.  Messages will be ordered from right to left.

My patches are just full of triggers like this.

Steve




More information about the Pd-list mailing list