[PD] style guide idea: [send foo] versus [; foo(

Matt Barber brbrofsvl at gmail.com
Fri Mar 20 14:34:18 CET 2009


> hmm.. generally this could be a good idea, but message sending is most useful
> when initialising a number of receives ie:
>
> [loadbang]
>  |
> |; init-1 6          /
> |; init-2 symbol foo |
> |; init-3 -2         \
>
> which is far more elegant than the the trigger/send replacement, especially
> with more fields..
>
> i think its important for students to recognise that this feature of messaging
> has a role to play, rather than trying to veil its use. in my experience
> people will tend to use [send foo] more often when they start pd, then begin
> abbreviating to [s foo] before they appreciate the msg shorthand [; foo[. but
> you are right it is a little confusing for new users..
>

Also note that some objects, e.g. [qlist], positively depend on the
message sending style.  My students who wanted to use them have often
wondered why we hadn't covered the two ways of sending more in depth.

Matt




More information about the Pd-list mailing list